Harbhajan backs Shubman over Prithvi for 1st Test against New Zealand

back icon
safari
12 Feb 2020 | 09:11 AM
authorPTI

Harbhajan backs Shubman over Prithvi for 1st Test against New Zealand

Prithvi Shaw, back in the Test squad after 16 months, is also a contender in the playing XI with his equally dazzling repertoire of strokes

heart

Share

Shubman Gill's stellar show in the recently-concluded India A series is an indicator that he is ready for Test debut, feels senior off-spinner Harbhajan Singh.

Shubman had scores of 83 and 204 not out batting in middle-order in the first 'A' Test and then scored a hundred opening in the second game, showing his versatility at different slots.

Prithvi Shaw, back in the Test squad after 16 months, is also a contender in the playing XI with his equally dazzling repertoire of strokes.

"Shubman should get his chance since he has been part of the team (as reserve opener) for quite a while without playing any Test match," Harbhajan, who has been Gill's state team skipper in white ball cricket, told PTI.

Their journeys have been intertwined since the U-19 days but in next 10 days, Prithvi and Shubman will provide skipper Virat Kohli and coach Ravi Shastri with a lot to ponder while fighting to be Mayank Agarwal's opening partner in first Test against New Zealand, starting February 21.

With Rohit Sharma being ruled out due to a hamstring injury and the in-form KL Rahul surprisingly ignored by the outgoing selection committee, India could go into the series with Agarwal, who has so far played nine Tests, as the senior opener.

India's woes could be compounded as Agarwal, despite his superb initiation in Test cricket, has been in wretched form, bagging a pair (0 in both innings) of the 'A' Test in Christchurch and failing in all three ODIs.

He also had a quiet couple of Ranji Trophy games.

However, Harbhajan feels that Agarwal should continue as the main opener.

"Mayank is a proven player in Test cricket and a top batsman. He understands his game very well. Just because of three ODI innings and a practice game, you don't drop him. It doesn't work like that," Harbhajan explained.

"He has been scoring lots of runs wherever he is playing, so I feel Mayank and Shubman should start in first Test," he added.

But, former India stumper Deep Dasgupta has a contrarian view and wants Prithvi to start in the playing XI.

"I fully understand that Shubman is in great form but remember one thing. It was Prithvi who made his Test debut before even Mayank. He did well and was first choice in Australia before getting injured," Dasgupta said.

Dasgupta, who was in New Zealand as an analyst, feels Prithvi looked in great touch throughout even though he didn't get a big knock.

"If Prithvi has been out injured, then he should rightfully get his place back in the side. Shubman has to wait."

Asked if Shubman, whose range of strokes is way more than Hanuma Vihari, could be accommodated in the middle-order, both replied in the negative.

"No, in the middle order, Vihari is a better bet. He has done nothing wrong in his limited opportunities. Shubman's real impact is when he is opening," said Harbhajan.

Dasgupta couldn't agree more.

"The last series that he played in the West Indies, he was adjudged Man of the Series so you can't pick Shubman in middle-order ahead of Vihari based on one double hundred." 

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
Shubman GillPrithvi Pankaj ShawIndiaIndia tour of New Zealand, 2020Harbhajan backs Shubman to make Test debut against New Zealand

Related Articles

safari
NEWS
Rahul ruled out of Australia series with wrist sprain
He will return to India and head to the National Cricket Academy for rehabilitation
userPTI
05 Jan 2021
safari
NEWS
India prefer Shaw over Gill, Saha instead of Pant
India's playing eleven for pink-ball Test against Australia announced
userPTI
16 Dec 2020
safari
NEWS
India hit Test mode with first warm-up game, look to sort combinations
The tour games will be a chance to sort out India's combinations both in the batting and bowling departments ahead of opening Day-Night Test
userPTI
05 Dec 2020
safari
NEWS
I don't see Dhoni wearing India jersey again: Harbhajan
Harbhajan said the current team ends ups losing 70 percent of its matches as it doesn't have match-winners lower down the batting order
userPTI
24 Apr 2020
safari
NEWS
Rohit ruled out of New Zealand tour, Agarwal in for ODIs
Mayank Agarwal will replace injured Rohit Sharma for the ODIs, while Shubman Gill will be included in the Test team as an opener
userPTI
03 Feb 2020
safari
NEWS
Prithvi Shaw set to join India A squad in New Zealand
The Mumbai opener had recently recovered from a shoulder injury
userPTI
15 Jan 2020
safari
NEWS
Pandya to play for India A in New Zealand
All-rounder will have to prove his fitness by playing two tour games and three one-day games
userPTI
24 Dec 2019
safari
NEWS
Shaw named India A squad for New Zealand tour
The opening batsman will look to take this opportunity to make a comeback into the Indian team
userPTI
23 Dec 2019
safari
NEWS
Attacking game in Tests strengthens Mayank's case for WI limited overs series
Agarwal was sent as a replacement during the World Cup but didn't get a game
userPTI
17 Nov 2019
safari
NEWS
Kohli hints at four-bowler strategy for series opener
The Indian captain also wanted the openers to make it count
userPTI
22 Aug 2019
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved