back icon
safari
30 Oct 2020 | 02:45 PM
authorAyaz Memon
A fair call by the BCCI
With opinions floating around Rohit Sharma’s exclusion from India’s squad to Australia, Ayaz Memon provides his thoughts on why BCCI made the right call

Rohit Sharma’s injury has come as a setback to Mumbai Indians, the franchise he captains in the Indian Premier League, as well as the Indian team, which takes off for a long tour Down Under as soon as the IPL ends.

Rohit, who looked in good nick with the bat and was captaining Mumbai Indians with customary aplomb in the defence of their IPL title, suffered a hamstring injury as the league phase of the tournament neared its end.

When he missed his first match in the tournament, it was thought that he might have been rested – since MI were doing extremely well then – or that he had a minor niggle from which he would recover pronto.

When he missed the next match too, concerns emerged about Rohit's fitness, but these were still muted, as the picture wasn’t entirely clear.

With the Indian media not allowed to cover the IPL in person because of Covid restrictions, the flow of information has been one-sided as follow up questions and stories have become almost impossible.

A few days later, however, the Indian selectors led by Sunil Joshi announced the three squads (for Tests, ODIs and T20s) to travel to Australia, it came as a bombshell.

Rohit, who was a certainty in all three formats – in fact also the vice-captain – featured in none of the squads. This was a clear giveaway that his injury was more serious than imagined.

The BCCI’s press release did not spell out details of the injury or the time he would take to recover. It merely mentioned that the Board’s medical team would be examining him and Ishant Sharma, also left out of the Australia-bound squads because of injury, regularly and update the team management.

Almost simultaneously, clips of Rohit at the Mumbai Indians nets were put out on social media, suggesting that the situation regarding his fitness was in control and that his return to the side was imminent.

However, Rohit missed MI’s next match too, and it did not need a Sherlock Holmes to deduce why the selectors had desisted from including him for the tour of Australia.

There was no quick-fix remedy for his injury that could heal him in a day, perhaps not even a week or two as was originally imagined, which made him ineligible for selection at this point in time.

Anxiousness of the franchise to see their captain back in action and in the saddle is understandable. He has been Mumbai Indians’ pre-eminent player, best batsman and brilliant captain, leading the team to four titles.

The management would be loath to lose Rohit's services at this crucial juncture of the tournament, with the last-four stage less than a week away.

While Mumbai Indians have already qualified for a place in the playoffs in spite of not having Rohit in the side, his presence there becomes crucial.

Moreover, Rohit himself would be eager to resume playing. He is the most successful captain in the history of the IPL, and one more title would give his already daunting reputation even more heft.

It’s not just about reputation and accolades only, of course. True blue sportspersons crave challenges and want to be in the thick of action especially on the big occasions.

One can understand the anguish of the player and the team management, but if the injury is more serious than understood earlier, as is now evident, the issue has to be addressed by the BCCI when it comes to India selection.

The franchise management could requisition the best medical opinion and services, and Rohit may even be willing to take a calculated risk. But that is restricted to playing for the league.

The onus on taking a call when selecting a player to represent the country is entirely on the BCCI and its decision should be final. Any other course of action could lead to mayhem.

The BCCI is the game’s arbiter in the country. In fact, franchises and the IPL are constituents of the BCCI, which has the sole authority to set standards for selecting India teams.

Where injury to players is concerned, there is a BCCI protocol in place, which includes an examination by the Board’s medical team, and recovery, and rehab in the National Cricket Academy.

Injured players who may not be interested in rehab in the NCA, or duck it for whatever reason, still have to subject themselves to scrutiny by the BCCI’s medical team or experts they may refer to for selection to the India side.

This protocol is terribly important, for the BCCI as not only it has to be even-handed, but also seen to be so when dealing with injuries to players, irrespective of their status.

If Ishant is ineligible for the Australia tour and Rishabh Pant is not considered for the ODI and T20 series in Australia because of injury and poor fitness, a different yardstick cannot be applied for Rohit.

This is particularly important in the times of Covid with countries (particularly Australia), having strict quarantine rules.

Ordinarily, it might be worth the risk taking a player who is likely to regain fitness. Flying in a replacement in an emergency would be a matter of a day or two. But not in current times.

Suppose Ishant or Rohit were included and then had a breakdown, the replacement would have to be quarantined for 15 days in Australia (subject to getting a visa), which would become an exercise in futility.

That the tour Down Under is long and the first match only starts on November 27, actually works to the advantage of Rohit and Ishant.

The BCCI has opted for the best process in the circumstances. Whatever the hard opinion of the medical team, a window has been kept open for them to be included in the squads at whatever stage of the tour provided they pass all necessary tests.

It can’t get fairer than that.

Share
Tags
Rohit Gurunath SharmaRishabh Rajendra PantIshant SharmaMumbai IndiansIndiaMumbai IndiansIndian Premier League, 2020India tour of Australia, 2020/21
Related Articles
NEWS
Hamstring getting better, keeping fingers crossed for Australia: Rohit Sharma
Rohit was added to the Test squad for the tour of Australia, shortly after he returned from injury to lead MI to their fifth IPL title
PTI
21 Nov 2020
NEWS
Rohit begins fitness training at NCA
Rohit and Ishant Sharma will fly to Australia together and undergo a 14-day quarantine before joining the team
PTI
19 Nov 2020
NEWS
Saha will be fit for Tests against Australia, insists Ganguly
The India wicketkeeper suffered a double hamstring injury during his participation in the IPL
Cricket.com Staff
14 Nov 2020
NEWS
Kohli to fly home after Adelaide Test
Rohit Sharma is believed to be rested for the limited-overs fixtures, but has been added to the Test squad
PTI
09 Nov 2020
NEWS
'Hamstring is absolutely fine,' confirms Rohit
The MI captain's injury forced the Indian selectors not to include him in the squad for the Australia tour
PTI
04 Nov 2020
NEWS
I am sure Rohit is mature enough to do what is best for him: Ganguly
The BCCI president said that the board will do everything possible to get an "asset like Rohit" back in the park
PTI
03 Nov 2020
NEWS
Rohit could be in danger of injuring himself again, as per medical report: Shastri
Rohit, who is recovering from a hamstring injury he suffered in the ongoing IPL, was left out of the India squad for the Australia tour
PTI
01 Nov 2020
NEWS
Rohit is getting better and will be back soon, assures Kieron Pollard
"There is a bright chance of Rohit playing in the playoffs. Having ensured a top-two finish, it gives him extra days to get fitter," a source privy to the senior cricketer's injury management told PTI on conditions of anonymity
PTI
31 Oct 2020
NEWS
Gavaskar calls for transparency from BCCI over Rohit's injury
The BCCI did not throw much light on Rohit's fitness and just stated that it is monitoring his progress
PTI
27 Oct 2020
NEWS
KL Rahul makes a comeback to Test Squad, Rohit and Ishant not named
BCCI announced India's squad for the upcoming tour of Australia
PTI
26 Oct 2020
Cricket like never before
Term of use
Privacy Policy
Cookies Policy
Follow us on
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved