An intense day defined by decision-making

back icon
safari
26 Dec 2021 | 05:11 PM
authorAnirudh Suresh

An intense day defined by decision-making

From Rahul’s clarity over which balls to leave, to Elgar and South Africa’s bold calls, Day 1 in Centurion was defined by decision making

South Africa’s ‘bold’ selection call backfires

After weeks of hype surrounding the supposed return of Duanne Olivier, who’d ripped the 2021/22 four-day-franchise season apart (28 wickets at 11.14 apiece) and has a scarcely-believable international record, Dean Elgar, at the toss, dropped a bombshell. The Proteas skipper revealed that it would be uncapped Marco Jansen, and not Olivier, who would take the place of Anrich Nortje in the starting XI. 

After what unfolded across 90 overs on Day 1, though, it is hard not to feel that the hosts erred big time with the decisive selection call.

Excited by the left-arm angle and his 6’8 frame, the Proteas management threw their weight behind Jansen, who was coming fresh off a decent outing against India A. On the day, however, despite beating the bat on multiple occasions, even inducing the outside edge of both the openers, his was a selection that bombed.

Jansen provided neither control nor consistency and conceded a staggering 12 boundaries as he ended with figures of 0/61 off his 17. Evidently, he simply looked too green, and his inexperience was exacerbated by the nerves that accompanied him all through the day, typified by the rank wide full-toss he delivered first-up.

Forget Jansen, the decision to leave out an in-form, warmed-up Olivier appeared to be a blunder immediately after the first spells of both Rabada and Ngidi. 

Having played no red-ball cricket since June, the senior pacers were both rusty and bowled too short and too wide up-front. Really, they wasted the new-ball, and their ineffectiveness up-front set the tone for the day. 


The need of the hour was a mature, experienced third-seamer who could bring calm but the greenness and over-keenness of Jansen added to the chaos. If nothing, Olivier should have made the XI owing to the mere fact that, prior to the series, he had more than 100 overs of red-ball bowling under his belt.

Leaving out Olivier was sure an unpopular call. By the looks of it, definitely not the right one too. 

England was not a false dawn - KL 2.0 is here 

Ahead of the series, we wondered if Rahul could double-down on his showing in England and actually deliver when the pressure was on, in the absence of Rohit Sharma and with the middle-order misfiring. 

Oof, if there ever was an emphatic ‘YES’, this was it. 

In England, we saw a completely different version of Rahul. He had a never-seen-before clarity in decision making and simply looked impregnable even in extreme bowler-friendly conditions. The conditions in Centurion today were not as extreme as they were in Lord’s or Edgbaston, but Rahul looked as good as he ever has donning the whites.

Rahul’s success in England four months ago was largely down to his off-stump awareness, the way he left the ball, and today in Centurion, it was once again his ‘leaving’ that laid the foundation for what was a stunning century. At times he channeled his inner Labuschagne by loudly yelling ‘no run’ in his own Bangalorean accent, but the discipline he showed today would undoubtedly have made Marnus proud.

KL Rahul's discipline in the first hour of Day 1

Overall Rahul left 29% of the balls he faced, but this figure stood at a staggering 37.3% after his first 150 balls. Sure the Proteas bowled too wide for the most part, but it was as if Rahul exactly knew where his off-stump was. The bowlers tried their best to tempt him but every attempt at drawing a false stroke in the fourth/fifth stump channel failed. Often they acknowledged the failure with a ‘damn you’ smirk.

And he left the balls in his own quirky fashion - playing a dummy straight drive before hiding the bat behind the pad. The same motion we witnessed in England. 

This ‘leaving’ is indeed the biggest change he’s made in his game; it is the cornerstone of his success. Prior to the England tour, Rahul left just 21.9% of the balls he faced in SENA countries. Already in nine innings since, this figure has risen to 29.2%. Early days, but the results are already there for the world to see. 

Loose technique and a fragile mind stalled Rahul’s Test career three years back, but now he seems unstoppable after having tightened both those things. 

He will know to not get too far ahead though. His first goal will be to ensure to convert this overnight score of 122* into a daddy hundred - something he failed to do in England.

ALSO READ - Older and wiser, Rahul returns to South Africa with aim of putting painful memories behind

Did Elgar make the right calls on the field?

Dean Elgar may or may not have had a say on the non-selection of Olivier. He did, however, have full control of everything that unfolded on the field on the first day. And it has to be said that the decision-making of the newly-appointed skipper, whose captaincy skills were barely tested in the Caribbean, at times left a lot to be desired.

When Kohli walked in to bat in the 41st over, on the back of two quick wickets, there was the opportunity to exert real pressure on the Indian skipper by bombarding him with seam, particularly with the wicket doing quite a bit. Understandably Elgar couldn’t have brought on Rabada, who had just finished a seven-over spell, but nothing stopped South Africa from deploying the other three seamers, at least for the next 30 minutes or so. 

But Jansen was pulled after a two-over spell, after which Maharaj was introduced. And flabbergastingly, the seamers did not bowl in tandem for the next 25 overs, with the left-arm spinner constantly occupying one end. 

Maharaj barely posed a threat - Kohli had 95% control against him - and this enabled the Indian skipper to quite comfortably motor along. It was a move that, inherently, seemed defensive in nature. 25 overs later seam was bowled in tandem to Kohli again, and it only took the Proteas three overs to see the back of the Indian skipper. 

The usage of Rabada was also questionable. With three of the four seamers being medium pacers, you would ideally want your quickest bowler - which in this case is Rabada - to throw everything at the batters in short bursts, but Elgar, up front, used the right-armer in a seven-over spell and a six-over spell. He was asked to do the donkey work and, as a result, Rabada’s speeds were down the whole day, with him averaging just 136 kphs. 

Perhaps if Rabada had been used more efficiently and effectively, he could have had an early crack at Kohli. Today, by the time Kohli first faced Rabada, he’d already seen off 59 balls. 

Elgar will certainly learn, but he cannot afford to have more such bad-captaincy days in this series. His side have already started to play catch-up.

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
South Africa vs IndiaIndia tour of South Africa, 2021/22IndiaSouth AfricaKL RahulDuanne OlivierMarco JansenDean ElgarKagiso RabadaKeshav Maharaj

Related Articles

safari
OPINION
Proteas – the fire that never burns out
Protea are the epitome of unique, named after Greek God Proteus
userAakash Sivasubramaniam
15 Jan 2022
safari
REPORT
Lone ranger Kohli stars for India as Proteas gain upper hand after day one
On a day where batting was tough, Indian skipper Virat Kohli top-scored with a well-crafted 79
userPTI
11 Jan 2022
safari
OPINION
The transformation of KL Rahul the Test batsman
We decode how Rahul has reinvented and transformed himself into a rock solid Test opener
userAnirudh Suresh
08 Jan 2022
safari
OPINION
Rahane suffers first golden duck as he becomes Olivier's 50th victim
Here are a few noteworthy stats from the first day of second Test between South Africa and India at The Wanderers, Johannesburg
userAnirudh Kasargod
03 Jan 2022
safari
ANALYSIS
South Africa tasked to lift themselves against fiery India
India eye series win in Johannesburg while South Africa aim to lift themselves after weary show in Centurion
userShubh Aggarwal
02 Jan 2022
safari
OPINION
Will we see an all-pace attack from both India and South Africa?
Ahead of the second Test, we look at the key selection calls either side will have to make
userAnirudh Suresh
02 Jan 2022
safari
REPORT
Gritty Elgar keeps South Africa’s hopes alive as India edge closer to victory
Bumrah struck twice in the final 30 minutes to put India in the driver’s seat
usercricket.com staff
29 Dec 2021
safari
OPINION
Marco Jansen: Wise head on young shoulders
After a tough outing in the first innings, the youngster produced a memorable performance on Day 4
userAnirudh Suresh
29 Dec 2021
safari
REPORT
Sensational Shami sizzles to put India in pole position in Centurion
The right-armer bowled a perfect spell to claim the sixth five-wicket haul of his Test career
usercricket.com staff
28 Dec 2021
safari
REPORT
Sensational Rahul puts South Africa to sword as India take charge in Centurion
The 29-year-old played a near-flawless knock to bring up his seventh Test ton
usercricket.com staff
26 Dec 2021
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved