Gabba pitch isn’t a good advertisement for Test cricket: Elgar

back icon
19 Dec 2022 | 01:25 PM staff

Gabba pitch isn’t a good advertisement for Test cricket: Elgar

ICC are yet to take a decision on the Gabba pitch

866 deliveries – that’s all it took for the much-awaited first Test between South Africa and Australia – to get a result. Five-and-a-half sessions after South Africa were put into bat, there was a result: Australia won by six wickets. Whilst there were several poor batting decisions and rash shots, the pitch wasn’t overly conducive for good batting. 

South African skipper Dean Elgar had a damming assessment of the conditions in Brisbane, calling it as a “poor advertisement” for the longest format of the game. Day one and two of the Gabba Test saw 34 wickets fall, with a slender batting average, that hasn’t been seen a whole lot in international cricket. 

"Let's not waste any time. You've got to ask yourself - is that a good advertisement for our format? Thirty-four wickets in two days; a pretty one-sided affair I would say. We want to see the game go to four or five days,” Dean Elgar said in the post-match press conference. 

"The nature of how it started to play, with some seriously steep bounce with the old ball, you're on a hiding to nothing as a batting unit. Only three batsmen applied themselves half decently and scored runs. I don't think that was a very good Test wicket."

Not just that, Elgar went on to even open up, alleging that the umpires ignored all questions about the playing conditions. 

"When 'KG' got Head out down leg [on Sunday], I said, 'How long does it go on for before it potentially is unsafe?' Then Nortje was bowling those short ones that were flying over our heads. I know the game was dead and buried. It was never to change or put a halt to the game, but that was where the umpires' discretion comes into play; not us as players,” he added.

However, Elgar refused to comment on the safety of the pitch, but insisted that there was plenty of room for improvement, owing to the divots. 

"I'm not a curator and I wouldn't know how to prepare a cricket pitch, but it was interesting to see how quickly this one actually did start divotting and how quickly the ball sped up; especially the new ball. Also today the older ball was flying through, which shouldn't be really happening. The divots had a big role to play, especially with the sideways movement and then up and down. And then the ball that's got that steep bounce, which is quite something to face."

Is there a possible debut? Elgar answered that question with diplomacy, stating that all options are still on the table, and necessarily did not point out at which direction the Proteas are heading. 

"All options are on the table. But you still have to go away and give your batters the confidence and the positivity. The guys in the changeroom have played enough cricket to know that this was maybe one of those instances where... let's be honest and let's be real about what's just happened,” he added.

Yet again, the South African skipper and one of their most crucial batters, pointed out at how they were “jaffaed” out in the conditions that aided the bowlers. 

“It's not like our guys were throwing wickets away. We were getting absolutely jaffaed out really. And [Australia] bowled properly. You've got to take all of that into consideration.”

shareGray Share
Australia vs South AfricaSouth Africa tour of Australia, 2022/23South AfricaDean Elgar

Related Articles

I still have the hunger and drive to lead South Africa: Elgar
Elgar is struggling with runs and is captain of a struggling South African team, but he is not giving up yet staff
08 Jan 2023
Disappointing that we aren’t playing more Tests this year: Elgar
Dean Elgar also emphasised that talk is cheap but the need of the hour is to go out and perform staff
03 Jan 2023
Will be a tough series but England are beatable: Elgar
Proteas’ skipper Dean Elgar also talked about being his biggest critic staff
15 Aug 2022
Elgar still prefers pace despite spinners guiding South Africa to huge win
Elgar praised “the pure skill level and intensity and consistency” of the two spinners, who took a combined 14 wickets in the match
04 Apr 2022
Series win against India will be massive for Elgar as leader: du Plessis
South Africa lost the first Test but bounced back in the next two encounters and won the three-match series 2-1 staff
21 Jan 2022
People outside don't know of what happens on-field: Virat Kohli on DRS controversy
The India skipper also felt that his team should avoid batting collapses in the future if they are to keep winning series staff
14 Jan 2022
Biggest game for us in the last 10-15 years: Elgar
Dean Elgar called the third Test at Newlands as their biggest game in last 10-15 years staff
10 Jan 2022
500 minutes of Dean Elgar at the Wanderers
Bruised, hurt, smacked but not defeated, Elgar stood against all odds to surmount Indian bowling Everest
userAakash Sivasubramaniam
06 Jan 2022
Playing in our backyard gives us an upper hand: Dean Elgar
South Africa captain Dean Elgar is hopeful of his team's chances against India ahead of the first Test in Centurion staff
24 Dec 2021
Our skill level hasn’t been where it should be: Elgar
The Proteas are currently seventh in the ICC Test rankings, their joint-lowest position ever staff
29 May 2021
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
@ 2020 | All rights reserved