Graeme Swann criticises England selectors for dropping Broad in first Test

back icon
safari
03 Aug 2020 | 09:47 AM
authorPTI

Graeme Swann criticises England selectors for dropping Broad in first Test

"Jimmy and Broady go together like Morecambe and Wise or Bonnie and Clyde," Swann said

heart

Share

Former off-spinner Graeme Swann has slammed selectors for splitting England's most successful new-ball pairing of Stuart Broad and James Anderson during the recently-concluded Test series against the West Indies, saying "you don't discard blokes with 500 Test wickets lightly".

England paid the price for dumping Broad in the first Test as they lost by four wickets at Southampton. With Jofra Archer missing the second Test due to a bio-secure breach, Broad returned to take six wickets as England bounced back with a 113-run win.

In the third Test, Broad was awarded the man of the match after he took 10 wickets to cross the 500-wicket mark and also scored a crucial 62 with the bat as England sealed the series with a 269-run win.

The experienced Anderson, on the other hand, was included in the first Test but rested in the second match before finally joining his long-time partner Broad in the third Test.

"How stupid did it look to break up England's most successful bowling partnership of all-time when we lost that first Test match?" Swann, who has taken 255 wickets in 60 Tests, was quoted as saying by 'Mirror.co.uk'.

"Jimmy and Broady have formed one of the most successful bowling double acts Test cricket has known. Why would you want to chuck it out before its sell-by date? I can understand the attraction of 90mph pace, and both Jofra and Woody are huge assets."

"But I'm sorry, you don't discard blokes with 500 Test wickets lightly," Swann said.

Broad and Anderson have captured 1,090 wickets between them, with 895 of those scalps coming in the 117 Tests they have played together.

"Jimmy and Broady go together like Morecambe and Wise or Bonnie and Clyde," Swann said.

Swann, a three-time Ashes winner, added that England should not mess with the two experienced bowlers and give them an equal opportunity to try and make it to the 2021 Ashes in Australia.

"You can't put a price on a bowler who runs in with the same passion and ability to make things happen in the 80th or 90th over of the day as the first," the 41-year-old said.

"But when people ask if they can carry on until the Ashes in 18 months, why would we look a gift horse in the mouth? When you have people with proven track records like Jimmy and Broady, you don't mess about with them.

"You can't say that we will definitely pick them to go to Australia in 2021, because they will be subject to the same standards of form and fitness as everyone else. But we've just seen what happens when you drop one of your all-time top bowlers without really knowing why you're doing it."

heart
shareGray Share
Tags

Related Articles

safari
NEWS
Swann wants Leach to be 'boring' against India
Leach doesn't bowl at the pace Monty Panesar bowled in 2012 but his consistency impresses Swann
userPTI
05 Feb 2021
safari
NEWS
Aus not best team anymore, Eng should focus on beating India: Swann
England would be touring India for a four-match Test series, beginning on February 5, followed by five T20 Internationals and three ODIs
userPTI
22 Jan 2021
safari
NEWS
'Unsung' Woakes eager to keep England place against Pakistan
The 31-year-old bowling allrounder was a key figure in England's recent 2-1 series win over the West Indies
userAFP
03 Aug 2020
safari
NEWS
Broad has a good chance of surpassing my Test wicket tally, says Anderson
"The way he has bowled the past two games has been phenomenal, and an absolute credit to himself and the work he's put in over the past few years," Anderson told Sky Sports
userPTI
29 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Broad says he could be last paceman in '500 club'
The 34-year-old Broad is only the seventh bowler in history to have taken 500 Test wickets and the fourth quick
userAFP
29 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Anderson, Broad complement each other for England, feel ex-cricketers
Former England captain Alec Stewart believes the duo should play together for England as long as it is possible
userPTI
26 Jul 2020
safari
ANALYSIS
How good is Stuart Broad?
While it may seem preposterous to question the credentials of someone who has taken 491 wickets in a Test career spanning 139 Tests, a closer analysis may paint a different story
userRavi Venkat
21 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Anderson's longevity inspires Broad
Broad believes he can follow the example of longstanding new-ball colleague James Anderson by extending his international career into his late 30s
userAFP
20 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Indian attack will bowl out any team cheaply: Swann
The Jasprit Bumrah-led Indian bowling unit is incredible feels the former England off-spinner
userPTI
16 Jul 2020
safari
OPINION
Stuart Broad: The perfect partner to James Anderson
On this day in 1986, Stuart Christopher John Broad, a lanky fast bowler was born in Nottingham. Broad is the second English bowler to bag 400 wickets in Tests
userAnirudh Kasargod
24 Jun 2020
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved