Ireland captain Porterfield unhappy with Foakes stumping

back icon
safari
06 May 2019 | 07:32 AM
authorAFP

Ireland captain Porterfield unhappy with Foakes stumping

"How long do you wait? We'll be playing 15-hour games if you wait that long," Porterfield said.

heart

Share

Ireland captain William Porterfield has blasted England’s Ben Foakes for his delayed stumping of Andrew Balbirnie during England’s one-day-international win in Dublin, saying matches could last “15 hours” if every wicket-keeper waited as long to try to effect a dismissal.


Balbirnie was on 29 at the Malahide ground on Friday when he missed an intended sweep off spinner Joe Denly.


Foakes gathered a wide delivery down the legside but, rather than whip the bails off immediately, he waited for Balbirnie to raise his back foot slightly -- thereby making the batsman out of his ground -- before breaking the stumps.


Third umpire Aleem Dar gave Balbirnie out after studying television replays, despite Porterfield convinced the appeal should have been dismissed as the delay meant the ball was “pretty much dead”.


“How long do you wait? We’ll be playing 15-hour games if you wait that long,” Porterfield said. “You can say it was great wicketkeeping or you can say it’s a bit of a grey area of how long he takes.


“The ball was pretty much dead. The batsman wasn’t going anywhere or overbalanced. It wasn’t like he had fallen over. 


“The keeper has waited for three or four seconds, if we do that all day it’s going be a pretty long game.”


The move divided pundits, with some saying that it went against the spirit of cricket, but one-day international debutant Foakes had a different view.


“It was quite wide down leg, but I got it back to the stumps,” he said.


“When it’s a sweep you think they might fall over and I just saw he lifted his foot and nicked them off.”


- ‘Spirit of cricket’ -


Ireland were eventually dismissed for 198 but then reduced England to 66 for five before man-of-the-match Foakes struck an unbeaten 61 to help see the visitors to a four-wicket win.


But it was his stumping rather than his batting that provoked plenty of debate, with former county bowler turned international broadcaster Alan Wilkins urging the International Cricket Council to take action.


“If the @ICC wishes to maintain its ‘Spirit of Cricket’ as part of the modern game, then the Ben Foakes ‘stumping’ in Malahide today should not be endorsed as ‘within the Spirit of the Game’,” Wilkins said on Twitter.


But there are many who feel the uncertainty surrounding what the ‘Spirit of Cricket’ means, as opposed to the precise nature of the sport’s rulebook or Laws, makes the concept more trouble than it’s worth.


Former England fast-medium bowler Mike Selvey, a long-serving cricket journalist, responded to Wilkins by tweeting: “The ‘Spirit’ doesn’t exist Wilko. 


“It’s an abstract concept that means only what an individual wants it to mean.”

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
IrelandEngland Stumping controversy

Related Articles

safari
REPORT
Ashwin's century puts India in commanding position
Axar took two wickets late in the day after Ashwin's hundred had helped India inch closer to victory in the second Test against England
userNitin Fernandes
15 Feb 2021
safari
REPORT
Ashwin's fifer puts India in control, hosts extend lead to 249
With a huge lead and nine wickets in hand in their second innings, India find themselves in the driver's seat in this Test
userNitin Fernandes
14 Feb 2021
safari
NEWS
This track looks darker and may start offering turn earlier: Ben Foakes
England won the first Test but it wasn't until the fourth day when the red-soil Chepauk pitch started offering sharp turn
userPTI
11 Feb 2021
safari
NEWS
Foakes finds it challenging to concentrate for long hours while standing up on turning tracks
Likely to don gloves against India after Buttler leaves, Foakes reflects on wicketkeeping challenges in the subcontinent
userPTI
31 Jan 2021
safari
ANALYSIS
Ireland seek consolation win in final ODI
Despite winning the first two games, England would not want to take their foot off the pedal
userHardik Worah
03 Aug 2020
safari
ANALYSIS
Can Ireland upset world champions England?
Ireland have an uphill task ahead of them as they take on England in the first of three ODIs at The Ageas Bowl in Southampton on Thursday
userNitin Fernandes
29 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Porterfield steps down as Ireland captain, Balbirnie takes over
Porterfield, who intends to keep playing international cricket, led the senior Irish side 253 times across all forms of the game
userAFP
08 Nov 2019
safari
NEWS
Porterfield says Lord's Test a 'pinnacle' for Ireland
Ireland face England in a four-day Test at Lord's.
userAFP
24 Jul 2019
safari
NEWS
Balbirnie reprimanded by ICC for showing dissent
One demerit point has been added against Balbirnie's disciplinary record.
userICC Media Release
17 May 2019
safari
ANALYSIS
Brilliant Foakes spurs England
Three Lions post edgy win against Ireland
userAFP
04 May 2019
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved