Jadeja on par with Ashwin in overseas conditions, says Harbhajan

back icon
safari
04 Aug 2021 | 06:18 PM
authorPTI

Jadeja on par with Ashwin in overseas conditions, says Harbhajan

Former Indian off-spinner Harbhajan Singh felt that Ravindra Jadeja's batting prowess in the lower-middle order gives India more depth

On seaming English tracks where spinners are going to be used sparingly, Ravindra Jadeja, with his restrictive wicket-to-wicket bowling and superior batting, was always going to trump number one tweaker, Ravichandran Ashwin, feels former India spinner Harbhajan Singh.

Ashwin, who picked up six wickets for Surrey in his last first-class game, was on Wednesday excluded for the first Test against England, as India went in with four fast bowlers.

"I guess if you would have played Ashwin, the tail would have been very long. You didn't know how much spin in fact will be used. Jaddu has bowled three out of 50 overs till tea.

"So overs that you will use spin, Jaddu can bowl those overs. And why do we jump to conclusion that Jaddu can't be used as a lone spinner," Harbhajan told PTI.

"And if you look at overseas performances, Jaddu has been a better batsman and has a solid presence in the lower order," Harbhajan, who has played more than 100 Tests for India, said.

Harbhajan feels that Jadeja, with 221 wickets in 52 matches, can never be clubbed as a second choice spinner, at least in overseas conditions where he can bat at No. 7.

"And is it so that Jaddu hasn't taken wickets? It's the first Test of the series, you want to win but at the same time, you would like to also have your defence prepared. You don't want to concede advantage on batting front and I feel it's fine if the team management thinks that way."

But isn't it a negative thought process to drop Ashwin, who has 400 plus wickets?

"Ideally, if you think that Ashwin is your front-line spinner then he should have played. But if the team management feels that Ashwin's presence makes the lower middle order a bit light, then perhaps they should be allowed to explore that angle too."

When it comes to overseas conditions, Jadeja, according to Harbhajan, is as good as Ashwin.

"If you look at overseas records, there isn't much to choose between Ash and Jaddu. Yes, you would feel hard done by if you have just picked six wickets for Surrey. But the considerations of Test cricket are different.

"Obviously, with six wickets in last first-class game, he was bound to be confident. But you also don't want a situation, where you are 75 for 5 and Ashwin is walking into bat."

He recently scored a hundred in Chennai on a different track?

"Chennai hundred was a different innings on a different track. Here the lower order players may struggle totalling 100 runs across five innings. So Chennai hundred can't be an indicator of playing him as an all-rounder at Trent Bridge."

The moment one picks four fast or seam bowlers, Harbhajan feels that the "workload is evenly shared" and all you need is tight lines from the overs that your spinner bowls.

"This surface in any case will not offer great turn. So if turn is not on offer, then play a guy, who can bat better and make the tail look a bit longer," Harbhajan signed off.


heart
shareGray Share
Tags
England vs IndiaIndia tour of England, 2021EnglandIndiaRavindra JadejaRavichandran Ashwin

Related Articles

safari
OPINION
It is not the end of the road for Ravichandran Ashwin this tour
Having narrowly missed out on an appearance at Lord’s, the conditions are stacked against the Indian off-spinner
userAakash Sivasubramaniam
22 Aug 2021
safari
OPINION
Ravichandran Ashwin's transformation in Tests bodes well for India
While Ashwin has been a match-winner over the years, the only criticism he has faced is over his performances in SENA countries. Can he set this record straight?
userPramod Ananth
13 Jun 2021
safari
NEWS
Siraj has shown remarkable improvement, should play WTC final: Harbhajan
Siraj should pip Ishant Sharma for the WTC final in Harbhajan's opinion
userPTI
10 Jun 2021
safari
OPINION
Self-believing Ashwin marks his own space
When the world was in lockdown, Ashwin was biding time to snatch back his rightful place
userSomesh Agarwal
27 Feb 2021
safari
NEWS
Ashwin surpasses Harbhajan for Test wickets in India, now only behind Kumble
R Ashwin is now the second highest-wicket taker in India in Test cricket
userPTI
14 Feb 2021
safari
OPINION
The Turbanator who prospered under an attacking captain
On this day, India’s most successful off-spinner was born
userSomesh Agarwal
03 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
I don't see Dhoni wearing India jersey again: Harbhajan
Harbhajan said the current team ends ups losing 70 percent of its matches as it doesn't have match-winners lower down the batting order
userPTI
24 Apr 2020
safari
NEWS
Bring Ashwin back in limited overs cricket: Harbhajan
Harbhajan, though, also believed that both Chahal and Kuldeep remain India’s best bet for providing breakthroughs
userPTI
20 Nov 2019
safari
NEWS
Shastri explains why Jadeja over Ashwin
The Saurashtra all-rounder has been preferred in both Tests against West Indies
userPTI
31 Aug 2019
safari
NEWS
Harbhajan tells India to stick with Yadav-Chahal
The two bowlers have 168 one-day international wickets between them
userAFP
19 Jun 2019
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved