MSK told me 'Sachin believes it was out': Harper on Tendulkar's controversial dismissal in 1999

back icon
safari
21 Jul 2020 | 07:12 PM
authorPTI

MSK told me 'Sachin believes it was out': Harper on Tendulkar's controversial dismissal in 1999

Recalling the controversial decision, Harper said he still thinks about that dismissal even after 20 years and stands by the call he made that day

heart

Share

Former ICC elite-level umpire Daryl Harper looks back at his controversial decision against Sachin Tendulkar in the 1999 Adelaide Test "everyday of my life" but says he proudly stands by what he believes was a correct decision.

A bouncer from Australian pace spearhead Glenn McGrath had Tendulkar ducking and the ball hit him on his shoulders. Officiating in the game, umpire Harper deemed it as LBW and, to India's surprise, raised his finger, igniting a debate.

Recalling the controversial decision, Harper said he still thinks about that dismissal even after 20 years and stands by the call he made that day.

"I look back on that Tendulkar decision every day of my life. It's not that I sleep badly or have nightmares and replays dancing through my brain. When I walk through my garage I am confronted by a huge canvas print of Sachin and Glenn McGrath, taken momentarily after the ball made contact," Harper told Asianet Newsable.

"You may be disappointed to know that I'm still extremely proud of that decision because I considered the action before me and applied the law without fear or favour."

India lost that Test badly and suffered a 0-3 whitewash.

Harper revealed that former chief selector MSK Prasad, who was the wicketkeeper in that game, told him when they met in 2018 that Tendulkar himself believes it was out.

"In December 2018, I met Indian selector MSK Prasad during a lunch at Adelaide Oval during the Australia-India Test match. We probably hadn't seen each other since that Test 20 years earlier at the same beautiful ground," Harper recalled.

"We embraced each other as we did in pre-COVID-19 days with a generous and respectful hug. MSK was the first to speak. 'Sachin said he was out Sachin said he was out', the Indian selector exclaimed excitedly. 'Well I thought he was too,' I confirmed.

"It was a very unusual dismissal. I've never seen anything similar and I've watched a lot of cricket over the years but I still believe it was correct," Harper said.

He further said that Tendulkar never brought up that topic with the umpire.

"I went on to umpire India in 26 Tests and 44 ODIs all over the world. I can't recall ever discussing that specific decision with the great man, but I believed Sachin and I were always on good terms.

"My decision followed an appeal. That's how cricket works. Players and umpire moved on. That's what I consider as the true spirit of cricket. That's why I almost always enjoyed umpiring India and especially in India," he added.

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
IndiaAustraliaSachin Ramesh TendulkarGlenn Donald McGrath

Related Articles

safari
ONTHISDAY
Chennai, 1998 – When Sachin Tendulkar was at his best
On this day (March 9) in 1998, Sachin Tendulkar unleashed one of the most breathtaking displays of attacking batting in Test cricket
userNitin Fernandes
09 Mar 2021
safari
NEWS
Let's just ban umpire's call: Daryl Harper
"Any contact with the ball on the stump will dislodge a bail. No 48 per cent, 49 per cent," Harper said
userPTI
02 Jan 2021
safari
NEWS
Sachin Tendulkar voices his opinion against umpire's call on LBW calls
The Master Blaster explained his reservations against the provision of umpire's call in LBW decisions
userPTI
11 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Ajmal still believes he got Tendulkar out in 2011 WC semi-final
Gould, who served on the ICC's elite panel of umpires, recently said that he would stand by his decision of giving Tendulkar out
userPTI
28 Apr 2020
safari
NEWS
I was clueless during my first Test: Tendulkar
The former India cricketer admitted that he was in tears after he was dismissed
userPTI
25 Apr 2020
safari
ONTHISDAY
When even a desert storm couldn’t stop Tendulkar
On this day in 1998, the batting great played one of the most memorable innings in ODIs
userPramod Ananth
22 Apr 2020
safari
ONTHISDAY
The arrival of Sachin Tendulkar – the opener
On this day, in 1994, Sachin Tendulkar walked out to open the innings in ODIs for India for the very first time
userAshish Pant
27 Mar 2020
safari
NEWS
Sachin Tendulkar wins best Laureus sporting moment
The Indian legend was carried on the shoulders of his teammates after India won the 2011 World Cup
userPTI
18 Feb 2020
safari
NEWS
Kohli not pleased with late DRS run-out call
Meanwhile, West Indies skipper Pollard said the right decision was made in the end
userPTI
16 Dec 2019
safari
NEWS
Third umpire to call front foot no-balls in India-WI series: ICC
The decision to make third umpire the adjudicator of front foot no-balls was taken in August this year
userPTI
05 Dec 2019
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved