No Indian in ICC's elite panel of umpires: Simon Taufel calls for structural review

back icon
safari
26 Nov 2019 | 08:57 AM
authorPTI

No Indian in ICC's elite panel of umpires: Simon Taufel calls for structural review

The Aussie said another another Indian can’t be expected in the elite panel anytime soon as the process “takes time”

heart

Share

Not a single Indian features in the ICC’s Elite Panel of Umpires right now and the celebrated Simon Taufel doesn’t foresee anyone making the cut in near future either as he feels it takes a decade to create one world-class official. 

S Ravi, who was India’s representative on the panel since 2015, was removed earlier this year after officiating in 33 Tests - including the Ashes - 48 ODIs and 18 T20 Internationals. 

“It does take 10 years to get to world-class. I remember when we started our programme in India in 2006 and finished in 2016, it took 10 years to get S Ravi into the elite panel,” the now-retired Taufel, who was adjudged the world’s no.1 umpire from 2004 to 2008, told PTI in an interview. 

“So there needs to be a rethink (from the BCCI). I am not sure if there is anything wrong necessarily. They need umpires and Sourav Ganguly (new BCCI boss) perhaps is on the right path when he talks about strengthening domestic cricket and hopefully umpiring is part of that programme,” he said. 

Taufel said another another Indian can’t be expected in the elite panel anytime soon as the process “takes time”. 

The 53-year-old Ravi was only the second Indian to enter the 12-member ICC elite panel of umpires after S Venkataraghavan. 

“...it is not just about the umpires themselves, it is about the structure and system. It is all about creating an environment where the umpires can grow. That means you need to have dedicated resources. You need to have an umpires’ manager, umpires’ coach, umpires’ trainer,” the Australian said. 

“We also need to create an environment where people feel safe and there is meritocracy,” he added. 

After his retirement in 2012, the 48-year-old Taufel served as ICC’s umpire performance and training manager until October 2015. 

Umpires are being scrutinised more than ever due to the increasing use of technology in the game, mainly the Decision Review System. In the past, Taufel has spoken about the extreme challenges of umpiring, maintaining that the art cannot be perfected. 

Asked if he would have liked to be an umpire in this technology-driven era where each mistake is magnified, Taufel said: “Not necessarily. It is just the nature of the beast, you got to keep adapting to the changing environments.” 

“...if you look at comments made by Tim Paine (Australia captain) during the recent Ashes series, he spoke about how difficult it is for captains to get the reviews right, they have greater appreciation for the umpires now. Umpiring is not for everyone. Technology also shows how many good decisions they make,” he pointed out. 

Taufel also stressed on the need for having best umpires in a Test match over two neutral umpires, which has been the norm since 2002. 

“When we have neutral umpires and we don’t care they come from and they make a mistake, we are not talking about where they are coming from, so the game comes first. It is not about whether the umpire is neutral or not. 

“It is about whether he is doing a good job or not. It should be merit-based. Why have we got different policies for ODI and Test cricket? Shouldn’t we be more aligned between the two formats?” asked Taufel. 

In ODIs and T20s, one on-field umpire is usually from the host nation and the other one is neutral. 

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
Simon TaufelS RaviICCElite Panel of UmpiresBCCI

Related Articles

safari
NEWS
Umpires Virender Sharma, Anil Chaudhary set to make their on-field Test debut
The duo will be joined by India's Elite Panel representative Nitin Menon, who has already officiated on-field in a previous Test match
userPTI
29 Jan 2021
safari
NEWS
Claire Polosak set to become first female match official in men's Test match
Polosak, who is a resident of New South Wales's Goulburn city, has also had the distinction of being the first female match official in a men's List A game in Australia
userPTI
06 Jan 2021
safari
NEWS
Ball-management will be our biggest challenge when cricket resumes: Nitin Menon
When things are back to normal, Menon hopes to be part of the iconic Ashes between England and Australia
userPTI
30 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
Nitin Menon becomes youngest umpire to enter ICC Elite Panel
The 36-year-old, who has officiated in three Tests, 24 ODIs and 16 T20Is, is only the third umpire from India to make it to the prestigious group after former captain Srinivas Venkatraghavan and Sundaram Ravi
userPTI
29 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
ICC Cricket Committee's call on using only local umpires poses huge challenge for Indian officials
With S Ravi dropped from the ICC elite panel of umpires last year, there is no Indian in the premier category from which match officials are usually picked for Tests
userPTI
19 May 2020
safari
NEWS
Cricket umpiring 'extremely challenging' in high-tech era, says Taufel
Taufel said he is in favour of experiments in the game but warned the authorities against making hasty changes
userAFP
19 Nov 2019
safari
NEWS
MCC stands firm on neutral umpires in Test matches
10 decisions by the on-field umpires were overturned by DRS in the first Ashes Test
userPTI
13 Aug 2019
safari
NEWS
Ponting calls for cricket to ditch neutral umpires
Shane Warne has called the umpiring in the first Ashes Test "horrific"
userAFP
03 Aug 2019
safari
NEWS
Giles unperturbed by 'six-run' decision
ECB director's comments come in the light of WC final controversy
userAFP
16 Jul 2019
safari
NEWS
England mistakenly awarded an extra run: Taufel
A freak fielding deflection off Ben Stokes’ bat that raced to the boundary saw the team awarded six runs with three balls to go.
userAFP
15 Jul 2019
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved