Physio not coming out after Jadeja getting hit is breach of protocol, feels Manjrekar

back icon
safari
04 Dec 2020 | 06:47 PM
authorPTI

Physio not coming out after Jadeja getting hit is breach of protocol, feels Manjrekar

In fact, former Australia cricketer Tom Moody also raised doubts about severity of Jadeja's injury since it didn't require medical attention

heart

Share

Indian physio Nitin Patel's absence on the field of play just after Ravindra Jadeja got hit on the head by a Mitchell Starc bouncer in the final over of the innings is a "breach" of concussion protocol, feels former India batsman-turned-commentator Sanjay Manjrekar.

Jadeja, who had also suffered a hamstring injury, was replaced by Yuzvendra Chahal, who got 3 for 25 to guide India to a 11-run victory in the first T20 International against Australia in Canberra on Friday (4 December 2020)

"There is one important breach of protocol that has happened," Manjrekar said on 'Sony Six' on Friday.

"I am sure the match referee will raise with India but one of the main things with that protocol, the moment you get hit on the head, they (physio) have to spend time with the batsman out there, asking how he feels.

"The physio (Nitin Patel in this case) has to come in and there are a certain set of questions that need to be asked. With Jadeja, it just happened, there was hardly any delay and he continued playing," Manjrekar said.

In fact, former Australia cricketer Tom Moody also raised doubts about severity of Jadeja's injury since it didn't require medical attention.

"I have no issue with Jadeja being substitute (sic) with Chahal. But I do have an issue with a Doctor & Physio not being present after Jadeja was struck on the helmet which I believe is protocol now?" asked former Australia cricketer Tom Moody, who is now a coach and a commentator.

Manjrekar on his part said that Jadeja continuing to bat didn't give any massive advantage to India as they added only nine runs after that but credibility of his injury can be questioned.

"He added just 9 runs, it wasn't a massive advantage. But after that (hit), there should have been at least 2-3 minutes where India support staff should have come out. And then it would have looked a little more credible."

However, Manjrekar agreed that match referee David Boon had no option but to allow India a concussion substitute.

"I would say one thing though, David Boon had no choice but to give India the concussion substitute because he would not have the courage to say he wouldn't allow it because, at the time of impact, no attention was given," he said.

"He had to give the concussion substitute once the request was made."

Manjrekar said that while the rules are made with good intentions, some thought needs to be put in so that teams don't misuse it.

"After this, there is going to be a lot of thought given to concussion substitute and the whole concept, because we, as players, there are rules made with good intentions, but we're masters at just trying to find a loophole in the rule to our own advantage.

"Whether India took advantage, I don't know but there's something that ICC will start looking at," Manjrekar said.

Manjrekar believes that ICC will have a look at the fact that the physio didn't come out to attend Jadeja.

"You know what ICC or referee will have a problem with this is there was no visit by the physio, nobody came, no time was taken to see him, he carried on playing."

The concept of like-for-like replacement can also be questioned since Jadeja had a hamstring injury.

"ICC will also make sure no team uses it unfairly, I am not suggesting India used it unfairly and got an unfair advantage. They want the like-for-like replacement. In this case, Jadeja, with the hamstring, is not the same bowler, as Chahal was," Manjrekar said.

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
IndiaRavindrasinh Anirudhsinh JadejaSanjay Vijay ManjrekarThomas Masson MoodyIndia tour of Australia, 2020/21Australia vs India - 1st T20I - India in Australia, 3 T20I Series, 2020

Related Articles

safari
NEWS
ICC should look at employing neutral doctor to make concussion call: Waugh
All-rounder Ravindra Jadeja was replaced by spinner Yuzvendra Chahal as a "concussion substitute" after he was hit on the head
userPTI
06 Dec 2020
safari
NEWS
Taylor warns against abuse of concussion substitute rule
Australia all-rounder Moises Henriques, however, did wonder if it was a like-for-like replacement
userPTI
05 Dec 2020
safari
NEWS
Chahal playing was within rules but don't agree with concussion substitutes: Gavaskar
Chahal replaced Jadeja, who got hit on the head, in the first T20 International
userPTI
05 Dec 2020
safari
NEWS
Jadeja complained of dizziness after returning to dressing room: Sanju Samson
Samson quite rightly didn't want to comment on whether Jadeja is out of the T20 series
userPTI
04 Dec 2020
safari
NEWS
We had no plans to play Chahal, but concussion replacement worked for us: Kohli
Chahal turned out to be the perfect concussion substitute after an injured Jadeja did his part with the bat in India's impressive 11-run victory
userPTI
04 Dec 2020
safari
NEWS
Going to play international cricket as long as I am beating the fastest sprinter: Dhoni tells Manjrekar
The commentator said he had a chat with Dhoni regarding his future in international cricket during Kohli's wedding
userPTI
08 Aug 2020
safari
NEWS
'Respect BCCI's decision,' says Manjrekar after being sacked from commentary panel
The former India batsman got embroiled in controversies in recent years for some of his views on air
userPTI
15 Mar 2020
safari
NEWS
Manjrekar's absence from commentary panel raises eyebrows
The former cricketer's name was not part of the commentary team in the recent India vs South Africa ODI series
userPTI
14 Mar 2020
safari
NEWS
'The sun will still rise' - India mourns World Cup shocker
India as a whole were still coming to terms with the unexpected semi-final loss to New Zealand
userAFP
11 Jul 2019
safari
NEWS
Put pressure on KL Rahul, rather than Dhoni, to deliver: Manjrekar
The cricketer-turned-commentator was speaking after India's loss against England.
userPTI
01 Jul 2019
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved