South Africa's quota takes away credit from black players' abilities, says Holding

back icon
safari
29 Oct 2021 | 06:28 PM
authorcricket.com staff

South Africa's quota takes away credit from black players' abilities, says Holding

West Indies pace great Michael Holding said South Africa's policy on black cricketers reduces them to a mere statistic

West Indies pace bowling great Michael Holding felt that the word 'quota' in South African cricket burdens black players while undermining their abilities. Holding spoke at the Cricket South Africa's Social Justice and Nation-Building (SJN) commission, Holding said that he understood why the country had the system in place and hoped that it will not necessary in the future.

"The quota system - I have heard that used on so many occasions when referring to South African cricketers of colour, that they are only there because the regulations say they have to be there. They are never given full credit for their abilities," Holding said.

"I understand initially why that was done. South Africa wanted to see a team and society that represents all of South Africa. And people in South Africa are in a hurry to see that. I suspect that people think that if it is not regulated it will happen very, very slowly and they want to see it happen quicker. I hope that eventually it will not be necessary," he added.

Holding pointed to the case of former Proteas pacer Makhaya Ntini who was the first black African to play for the country and had to carry the tag of quota throughout his international career for over a decade.

"That is a burden that Makhaya Ntini carried throughout his career. He spoke about it when I spoke to him for the book and I think it is unfair. He was a fantastic cricketer, his record proves that, everybody knows that, and not just in the latter stages of his career," Holding said of Ntini, who claimed 390 Test wickets in 101 matches.

"From the early stages of his career he proved his worth and that he belonged there but kept on carrying that burden of being pointed out as being there only because regulations said he should be there."

The legendary Windies pacer recalled the account of discrimination Ntini faced during his playing days.

"He would go for breakfast in the morning, he would sit at a table and his team-mates would come in and sit at another table and leave him by himself at his table. Other team-mates would come in and go and join their other team-mates and leave him at his table. He was trying to comfort himself by saying maybe they just have things they need to discuss among themselves. Later it grew on him that that was not really the reason. He was not considered one of them. He was not considered a full-fledged member of the team. I played cricket. I know about committees that are formed within teams, I know about senior members within teams. There were committees formed within the team, supposedly senior members of the team to discuss things, and he was never called to be a part of that committee. People who joined the team long after him automatically became senior because of the colour of their skin."

Holding also advocated for a shifting procedure, specifically the scholarship system which takes children out of disadvantaged areas and into elite schools. 

"What I would like to see is opportunities being equal and everyone being given an opportunity to develop. I don't like the idea of scouts going out and handpicking people and taking them out of their comfort zone, somewhere else for them to try and develop. I would like to see the development process start from where that person is from. Go there and put the infrastructure in place," he said.

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
South AfricaMakhaya Ntini

Related Articles

safari
NEWS
Racism still part of ecosystem, South African cricket administration in chaos: Rhodes
Rhodes, who is in Dubai as fielding coach of Kings XI Punjab ahead of the IPL, feels not much will change in South African cricket till the administrative chaos ends
userPTI
09 Sep 2020
safari
NEWS
A maverick who destroyed every opposition: Holding lauds Dhoni
The stumper-batsman is widely considered one of the greatest captains in international cricket and earned respect for his foresight on the cricket field
userPTI
23 Aug 2020
safari
NEWS
Archer should forget about "outside noise" and focus on becoming a great fast bowler: Holding
The 66-year-old said the England side needs to be supportive of Archer which will help the Barbados-born speedster
userPTI
24 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
I was forever lonely, had to overcome isolation: Ntini reveals about time in SA team
Ntini said he used to avoid travelling in the team bus and preferred running to the stadium to deal with the isolation
userPTI
17 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Ashwell Prince speaks on racism calling South Africa's system 'broken'
The former South African cricketer claims there had "never been any unity" in the national team
userPTI
11 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Entertainment in any sport is determined by standard of play, not by what is happening in the stands: Holding
The former West Indies bowler gave an example of how the quality of Premier League games didn't take a hit despite matches being played in front of empty stands
userPTI
28 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
Pakistan team would be better off in England than in Pakistan: Holding
Pakistan are scheduled to leave for the UK on June 28 to play three Tests and as many T20 Internationals starting in August
userPTI
25 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
BCCI has every right to hold IPL if T20 World Cup is postponed: Holding
The former tearaway-pacer-turned-commentator further said the proposal to ban saliva to shine balls would not pose any "practical" problems
userPTI
08 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
Makhaya Ntini floored by India U-19s, says watch out for IPL players Jaiswal, Tyagi
Ntini reckons India's U19 squad is at par with their senior counterparts
userPTI
12 Jan 2020
safari
NEWS
It all started from U-19 World Cup for players such as Kohli: Ntini
The next edition will be held in South Africa from January 17 to February 9
userPTI
02 Jan 2020
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved