Top Court dismisses PIL insinuating violation of noise pollution norms during IPL

back icon
safari
15 Jul 2019 | 10:42 AM
authorPTI

Top Court dismisses PIL insinuating violation of noise pollution norms during IPL

Kapil Soni, an advocate, filed the PIL in 2014, alleging that during the IPL matches held in 2013 in Mumbai and Pune, the noise pollution norms and regulations were violated

heart

Share

The Bombay High Court on Monday dismissed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) alleging violation of noise pollution norms during IPL matches, saying let there be some cacophony in society as people are bound to cheer and shout during cricket matches. Kapil Soni, an advocate, filed the PIL in 2014, alleging that during the IPL matches held in 2013 at Mumbai’s Wankhede stadium and Pune’s Subrata Roy Sahara stadium, the noise pollution norms and regulations were violated. 

Hence, he demanded that legal action be initiated against the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) and the Maharashtra Cricket Association (MCA) and heavy penalty be imposed. According to the petition, during the 2013 Indian Premier League (IPL), the matches held in Pune and Mumbai began at 8 pm and went on till midnight, including the prize distribution ceremony. 

A division bench of Chief Justice Pradeep Nandrajog and Justice N M Jamdar said on Monday that during cricket matches, when a player hits a boundary or a sixer or when a wicket is taken, people are bound to cheer and shout. “Let the society have some fun and enjoyment... let there be some cacophony in it. Let people enjoy,” Chief Justice Nandrajog said. 

The bench also took note of the fact that the petitioner was a resident of Dahisar, located around 40 km away from the Wankhede stadium in south Mumbai. “How is the petitioner affected by something that is happening so far away? None of those people who stay in the vicinity of the stadium have complained,” the court said while dismissing the petition. 

Soni, in his PIL, claimed loudspeakers were being used to play music during the matches and even after the prescribed time deadline of 10 pm, and thus violated provisions of the Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Act.

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
IPLIndian Premier LeagueIPL 2013

Related Articles

safari
NEWS
IPL 2021 likely to kick off April 11 onwards
The auction for the 2021 edition is currently scheduled for February 18, in Chennai
userCricket.com Staff
31 Jan 2021
safari
NEWS
SC pushes hearing to January; Ganguly, Jay Shah to continue
The apex court has now posted some pending interim applications for hearing in the third week of January next year
userPTI
09 Dec 2020
safari
NEWS
Pakistan vs Zimbabwe T20Is shifted to Rawalpindi
The three-match T20I series originally scheduled to take place in Lahore has been moved due to poor air quality in the city
userPTI
24 Oct 2020
safari
NEWS
PCB look to pacify PSL franchises who have taken them to court
According to the franchisees, the financial model was tilted in favour of the PCB which had earned billions from the PSL in the last five years, even as the team owners suffered losses.
userPTI
29 Sep 2020
safari
NEWS
MCA urges BCCI to host Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy in Mumbai
MCA wants BCCI to ensure that players are tested for COVID-19 on their arrival in Mumbai hotels and again three to four days before the tournament
userPTI
20 Sep 2020
safari
NEWS
Fazal-e-Miran Chauhan appointed independent adjudicator to hear Saleem Malik's plea
The former Pakistan captain is seeking clearance from PCB to return to cricket-related activities
userPTI
15 Sep 2020
safari
NEWS
Will appeal to SC for exemption of Ganguly's cooling off period: IPL petitioner Verma
As per the new BCCI constitution based on justice RM Lodha committee's reforms, any person who has been an office bearer in state as well as BCCI for consecutive period of six years will have to go for compulsory cooling off period of three years
userPTI
24 Mar 2020
safari
NEWS
SC refuses urgent hearing on plea to postpone IPL-2020
The plea has sought a direction to the Centre to take "effective, strong and war footing steps" to curb the outbreak of coronavirus
userPTI
12 Mar 2020
safari
NEWS
Guwahati to host two games of Rajasthan Royals in IPL 2020
They will play their remaining five home matches at their designated home ground of Sawai Mansingh Stadium
userPTI
27 Feb 2020
safari
NEWS
Shakib episode will affect Bangla performance, concedes coach Domingo
Domingo also weighed in on the prevailing weather conditions in Delhi
userPTI
01 Nov 2019
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved