Vaseline is no replacement for saliva, feel Nehra, Harbhajan

back icon
safari
25 Apr 2020 | 11:36 AM
author
PTI

Vaseline is no replacement for saliva, feel Nehra, Harbhajan

ICC is considering legalising ball tampering post COVID-19 by using artificial substances to prevent virus spread

heart

Share

Saliva and sweat are components that cannot be entirely done away with, insist a few distinguished India cricketers, as the ICC contemplates legalising ball tampering post COVID-19 by using artificial substances to prevent virus spread. Former India pacer Ashish Nehra and spinner Harbhajan Singh feel that saliva's use in shining the ball is a "must". Ex-opener Aakash Chopra, while being open to the idea, wants to know where one can draw the line.

While discussions are at nascent stage, questions are already being asked about what external substances could be used if ball tampering becomes legal? Is it going to be bottle cap in pocket to scuff up one side of the ball, vaseline to shine (made famous by John Lever) or chain zipper?

"Get one thing clear at the onset. The ball will not swing if you don't apply sweat or saliva on the ball. That's basic necessity of swing bowling. The moment ball gets scuffed up from one side, sweat and saliva must be applied on the other side," Nehra, who completely shot down the idea of using external substances, told PTI.

He went on to explain why vaseline alone can't help a pacer. "Now let's understand why do you need saliva? Sweat is heavier than saliva but both are heavy enough to make one side of the ball heavier for reverse swing. Vaseline comes into the picture only after sweat and saliva, not before that.

"It is lighter and doesn't even ensure conventional swing. It can keep the shine but doesn't make the ball heavy," the World Cup-winning former pacer said.

Nehra then gave the example of Englishman Lever who created a furore during his team's 1976 tour of India by applying vaseline during a Test match. "I can bet Lever used sweat and saliva and then applied vaseline. Vaseline only helps the ball to skid and nothing more. You apply vaseline only, the ball will just go straight. You can check that with any fast bowler," he said.

Harbhajan also agreed that saliva if one has already chewed mint, which has sugar in it, makes it heavier. But when it comes to using external substance, he wants to know what can be the options. "It's not that murray mint can be used without putting it in your mouth. The coat of sugar on the saliva makes it heavier after one side gets scuffed. A scuffed up ball is also good for spinners as it ensures a better grip than a shiny new ball. But my question is, if you allow, what's the limit?

"Suppose you legalise ball tampering and let people use bottle cap. Now the ball starts reversing from the fifth over. Is it fair? Or may be umpires come into play and they tell you now is the time when you can use external substance.

"I mean, in any case, taking saliva out of equation means taking swing out which may not be good idea," said the owner of 700-plus international wickets.

Former opener Chopra said that unless the ICC comes up with something concrete as to what are the external elements that can be used "it's all conjecture". "I always felt that allowing mint shouldn't be a problem. But now they have gone to the extent that they don't want to allow mint. But now if you change rule, ok let's allow them to use finger nails, vaseline, now where does it stop God knows," said Chopra, who is also a respected analyst.

"Spinners won't mind as they do get a bit of drift if the ball is kept shiny from one side. So they won't actually mind as long as you are not landing the shiny surface of the ball," Chopra said.

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
Harbhajan SinghAshish NehraAakash ChopraIndia

Related Articles

safari
NEWS
Uthappa spotted purportedly applying saliva on ball
The video of Uthappa purportedly applying saliva on the ball after he dropped Sunil Narine in the fifth ball of third over went viral on social media
userPTI
30 Sep 2020
safari
NEWS
Bowling in times of COVID-19: Forget reverse swing for now, says Pathan
The ICC banned the use of saliva to shine the ball due to the threat of COVID-19 infection
userPTI
14 Jul 2020
safari
NEWS
Saliva ban favouring batsmen is bloody storm in a teacup: Greg Chappell
Ball manufacturer Kookaburra have developed wax applicator to polish cricket balls but Chappell said it won't be needed
userPTI
15 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
Wasim Akram warns saliva ban will make bowlers 'robots'
"Sweat is just something of an add-on, a top-up. Too much use of sweat will leave the cricket ball too wet," he said
userAFP
10 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
What happens to bowlers in England where they don't sweat: Tendulkar on Saliva ban
Tendulkar also wants the introduction of a second new ball in Tests after every "50 or 55" overs to aid fast bowlers on unresponsive pitches
userPTI
10 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
ICC should wait for a suitable time to host T20 World Cup: Akram
On May 28, the ICC had deferred a decision on the fate of the T20 World Cup till June 10
userPTI
05 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
Sweat not as effective as saliva: Sri Lanka bowlers convey to coach Arthur
Sri Lankan cricketers returned to training earlier this week and will remain in a highly protected environment during the 12-day camp
userPTI
04 Jun 2020
safari
NEWS
Cummins accepts risk of using saliva but says cricket need alternate option to shine ball
Cummins, currently world's no.1 Test bowler, said sweat is a viable option to keep the ball shining
userPTI
20 May 2020
safari
NEWS
COVID-19 effect: Legalisation of ball-tampering could be considered, says report
The matter of saliva being unsafe was raised by the ICC's medical committee and it would be addressed before cricket resumes
userPTI
24 Apr 2020
safari
NEWS
To spit or not: Bowlers face 'saliva' conundrum in post COVID-19 scenario
In the wake of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal, the scrutiny on ball maintenance has only increased
userPTI
20 Apr 2020
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved