Will we see an all-pace attack from both India and South Africa?

back icon
safari
02 Jan 2022 | 06:46 AM
authorAnirudh Suresh

Will we see an all-pace attack from both India and South Africa?

Ahead of the second Test, we look at the key selection calls either side will have to make

An enthralling battle in Centurion saw India eventually comprehensively come out on top, winning the first Test by 113 runs, and the caravan will now move to Johannesburg, a place where the visitors have never lost a Test. The onus will be on the hosts to put up a much-stronger showing, and it is likely that the Proteas will make at least a couple of changes to the starting XI, if not more. 

India should ideally field an unchanged XI, but could there be room for the visitors to throw in a change or two? Ahead of the second Test, we look at the selection conundrums faced by both sides.

India

Could one of Ashwin or Thakur sit out the second Test?

In Centurion there was little purchase for Ashwin, but he still did a fine hold-up job, conceding at an ER of 2.5 whilst taking two wickets. He also starred in a crucial 35-run partnership with Rishabh Pant in the second innings.

But despite chipping in as best as he could, Ashwin’s spot in the XI might not be guaranteed. 

The Wanderers is one of the most pace-friendly venues in the world, with pacers, since 2014, having taken 229 of the 245 non run-out wickets to have fallen (89%). It is worth remembering that the last time India played South Africa at the Wanderers, they opted to field an all-pace attack. 

Hence, with both Ishant and Umesh waiting in the shed, there could be every chance of the management opting to field an all-pace attack.

Conversely, the management could ask Ashwin to do a defensive job and bring in Umesh or Ishant in place of Shardul Thakur, who was by far the most innocuous seamer in the first Test. Despite taking the crucial wicket of Quinton de Kock in the first innings, Thakur lacked discipline and conceded runs at an ER of 4.60. In the second innings, he bowled just 5 of the 68 overs. 

Keeping Ashwin and replacing Thakur with a more potent pacer could hence be an option. However, that would mean sacrificing batting depth.

Unchanged top five likely, Pujara only player whose spot 100% not fixed 

Even before a single ball had been bowled, head coach Rahul Dravid upset a majority of the fanbase by preferring Ajinkya Rahane over Shreyas Iyer and Hanuma Vihari. But the decision stood vindicated at the end of the game as the veteran struck a free-flowing 48 in the first innings before following it up with a swashbuckling 20 in the second. Across the course of the two innings, he looked like a man born to excel in these conditions. He will, therefore, in all likelihood, retain his spot in the XI should he stay fit.

Cheteshwar Pujara, on the other hand, struggled in the first Test with scores of 0 and 16, meaning he currently stands as the only player in the top five whose spot is not assured. But India are unlikely to axe him after two failures, that too after having convincingly won the game. Should they take the very bold call of dropping Pujara, though, one would have to assume that it will be Vihari - and not Iyer - who will bat at No.3. Not only has Vihari already spent over a month in South Africa, he also batted in the Top 4 for India ‘A’.

South Africa 

Duanne Olivier set to return, but who will he replace?

CSA revealed after day one of the first Test that Duanne Olivier had been rested from the Centurion game as ‘precaution’, meaning he will all but return for the second Test. But the question is - who does he replace in the XI?

After the first innings of the first Test, it would have been easy to pick Marco Jansen. But Jansen bounced back in the second innings with a four-fer, and he also showed across both the innings that he has decent batting potential in him. The variety he brings with the left-arm angle might also be an incentive for the hosts to keep the youngster in the XI.

Given Ngidi and Rabada are locks, could South Africa, therefore, possibly drop Keshav Maharaj? The left-arm spinner did not pose a threat or provide control in the first innings, and remarkably did not even bowl in the second dig. We’ve already revealed above how Wanderers is a graveyard for spinners, and in 2018 the Proteas benched Maharaj in Johannesburg. Olivier coming in for the left-arm spinner, therefore, could be a realistic option.

The other left-field option is to bring Olivier in for Wiaan Mulder. Supposedly a batting all-rounder, Mulder averages 14 with the bat after 7 Tests, and registered scores of 12 and 1 in the first Test. He also did not threaten too much with the ball. However, such a move will mean Jansen and Rabada batting at 7 and 8 respectively. Might be a spot too high for both the players.

Kyle Verreynne primed to take QDK's spot; 6 or 7 batters remains the only question

In Kyle Verreynne, a keeper who averages almost 52 with the bat in first-class cricket and has already debuted for the Proteas, South Africa have a very able de Kock replacement. All of Markram, Petersen, Van der Dussen and Bavuma are also likely to retain their places unless one of them suffers a late injury.

The only question for South Africa in the batting department, then, is if they want to field an extra batter and push Verreynne to No.7. In the first Test it was evident that batting is the hosts’ weakest facet, and bolstering it would make logical sense. 

The only options available, however, are Sarel Erwee and wicket-keeper Ryan Rickelton, two players who have predominantly batted in the Top 3 in first-class cricket. 

Bringing either of those two in cannot be ruled out, but it looks likely that the hosts will continue with the current combination. 

Should South Africa want to field four pacers, a spinner and have batting depth at the same time, they also have the option of bringing in someone like a George Linde for Mulder (bringing in Olivier for Maharaj). Linde averages 28.00 with the ball in Tests and has passed 20 four times (out of six) with the bat. 

heart
shareGray Share
Tags
South Africa vs IndiaIndia tour of South Africa, 2021/22IndiaSouth AfricaRavichandran AshwinShardul ThakurDuanne OlivierKeshav Maharaj

Related Articles

safari
ANALYSIS
No dearth of motivation as India, South Africa brace for Cape Town showdown
Newlands is all set to oversee one of the most anticipated showdowns in recent history
userAnirudh Suresh
10 Jan 2022
safari
OPINION
Rahane suffers first golden duck as he becomes Olivier's 50th victim
Here are a few noteworthy stats from the first day of second Test between South Africa and India at The Wanderers, Johannesburg
userAnirudh Kasargod
03 Jan 2022
safari
REPORT
South Africa: asking the right questions at Wanderers
Hitting the lengths that matter, asking the questions that are tough defines South African bowling
userAakash Sivasubramaniam
03 Jan 2022
safari
NEWS
Kohli out of Wanderers Test due back injury; Rahul to lead for first time
The India captain will not play his 100th Test on this tour as a result
usercricket.com staff
03 Jan 2022
safari
ANALYSIS
South Africa tasked to lift themselves against fiery India
India eye series win in Johannesburg while South Africa aim to lift themselves after weary show in Centurion
userShubh Aggarwal
02 Jan 2022
safari
REPORT
Sensational Shami sizzles to put India in pole position in Centurion
The right-armer bowled a perfect spell to claim the sixth five-wicket haul of his Test career
usercricket.com staff
28 Dec 2021
safari
NEWS
India could create history on this tour: JP Duminy
The former South African player shared insights on the upcoming series and the possible combinations for the two sides heading into the opening game
usercricket.com staff
25 Dec 2021
safari
ANALYSIS
Cricket in focus again as India aim to materialize their favorites tag
South Africa's transition provides India their best chance to win a Test series in the Rainbow nation
userShubh Aggarwal
25 Dec 2021
safari
OPINION
Let’s talk Cricket! Shall we?
How will India cope in the absence of Rohit and Jadeja? What will be India's bowling combination?
userBastab K Parida
23 Dec 2021
safari
OPINION
The fresh faces picked to represent the Protea fire
Going through the new names in the 21-man South Africa squad for the Test series against India
usercricket.com staff
21 Dec 2021
logo
Cricket like never before
Follow us on
FacebookTwitterLinkedin
@ 2020 cricket.com | All rights reserved